|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 3 post(s) |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
22
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 08:21:00 -
[1] - Quote
Victim? Really people? >.>
So let me get this straight....
1. Idiot #1 falls for Idiot #2's isk doubling scam and is invited to play in a 'bonus room' 2. Idiot #2 askes idiot #1 to TS, and he agrees 3. Idiot #1 makes himself look like an ass in front of idiot #2 and his friends. 4. Idiot #2 tells Idiot #1 he gets nothing. 5. Idiot #1 throws a fit, and is marred by his own decision to go along with this
In this case the 'victim' only fell victim to his own stupidity and greed. No one was pointing a gun to this guys face forcing him to participate in this. He could have refused to come on TS, and once he made the decision to join, he could have left at anytime.
Lets be serious here, I'm all for victims rights as much as the next guy/gal is, but unlike a true victim of a true crime this guy actually had choices available to him to avoid this and he choose greed in a video game, over being humiliated. Sorry, but in this case the 'victim' bought this on himself and I can't support the O.P's motive in this tread at this time.
By the way, to the people saying that erotica should be banned for this:
The only in game interaction that took place here was the giving of isk, and contracting of assets which is totally not against the rules. The 'bonus room' as it were took place entirely on a private TS server which CCP has no jurisdiction. |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
23
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 08:32:00 -
[2] - Quote
Big Lynx wrote:
very stubborn point of view. there are ppl in this world who can't defend themselves (Sakhor) and ppl who take advantage out of it (Ero). Everyone who approves or defends that behaviour of Ero's group has a distorted perception of healthy social interaction. period.
And where did I say I support ero and his group of friends? >.>
All I said is that the person who got scammed in this case is equally at fault if not more so. Where as a **** victim, robbery victim, or murder victim doesn't have any choice weather or not they become a victim or not, this guy and every idiot who has or will fall for this scam does have a choice. That choice is don't be a greedy bastard...
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
24
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 08:36:00 -
[3] - Quote
Big Lynx wrote:Asia Leigh wrote:Big Lynx wrote:
very stubborn point of view. there are ppl in this world who can't defend themselves (Sakhor) and ppl who take advantage out of it (Ero). Everyone who approves or defends that behaviour of Ero's group has a distorted perception of healthy social interaction. period.
And where did I say I support ero and his group of friends? >.> All I said is that the person who got scammed in this case is equally at fault if not more so. Where as a **** victim, robbery victim, or murder victim doesn't have any choice weather or not they become a victim or not, this guy and every idiot who has or will fall for this scam does have a choice. That choice is don't be a greedy bastard... u still don't get it mate. 
And you sir are missing the point entirely...
Its okay I'll wait for you to catch up >.> |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
24
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 08:44:00 -
[4] - Quote
Trance Oskold wrote:Asia Leigh wrote:Big Lynx wrote:
very stubborn point of view. there are ppl in this world who can't defend themselves (Sakhor) and ppl who take advantage out of it (Ero). Everyone who approves or defends that behaviour of Ero's group has a distorted perception of healthy social interaction. period.
And where did I say I support ero and his group of friends? >.> All I said is that the person who got scammed in this case is equally at fault if not more so. Where as a **** victim, robbery victim, or murder victim doesn't have any choice weather or not they become a victim or not, this guy and every idiot who has or will fall for this scam does have a choice. That choice is don't be a greedy bastard... It's actually more than that now. Since this has been pointed out and there is an audio recording of the event that's been published in many different places online, it's making CCP look bad. They will have to take action of some sort.
True, but from my understanding all of his 'bonus room' scams are recorded and posted on his blog. This is something that has been going on for months now and really isn't anything new. If they were going to do anything about this they would have done so long ago.
And for the last time, I am in no way condoning what ero is doing, as I'm not a scammer myself and don't condone it. Just saying that everything done seems to be with in the rules, and to bend them in this case because of some bad press, will put the game heading in a direction we would rather not have it go.
Just my 2 cents
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
24
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 08:51:00 -
[5] - Quote
Big Lynx wrote: sorry mate. your one sided view of things has paralyzed my legs.
One sided how? I wish you would reread my first post in this thread. I call them both idiots not just one or the other. Can we just agree that both parties behaved extremely poorly and some of this may have been bought on himself due to his own stupidity. Nowhere did I say I absolved ero of any responsibility here. Just saying that the guy who got scammed did have a choice to participate or not to participate...
That's all my post was trying to get through.
Still waiting for you to catch up >.>
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
26
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 10:16:00 -
[6] - Quote
One Eyed Runner wrote:6 accounts of mine were cancelled because of this so will wait and see what if anything CCP does
Can I have your stuff? |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
26
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 11:09:00 -
[7] - Quote
Why is the TOS arghument still going on?
Quote:25. CCP reserves the right to close, temporarily or permanently, any userGÇÖs account without advance notice as we deem necessary. Furthermore, we reserve the right to delete all user accounts or inventory of characters as warranted.
They can pretty much ban you for any reason or no reason at all.
By the way I have been operating under the impression that this was just an other I got scammed Q.Q troll bait, because I have been at work and the bonus round recordings have been known to not be safe for work. When I get home I'll listent to it and update my opinion on the matter. |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
26
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 12:38:00 -
[8] - Quote
Okay... After listening to the recording...
This isn't exactly new. It has only been circulating around the C&P forums for about a month or so. When those posts came up, everyone treated it as "Whaa I got scammed" troll bait thread, it would degrade into trolling and personal attacks being thrown back and forth. ISD would come lock the thread and clean it up and with in 3 hours a new thread was started.
When these threads were circulating through no one seemed to care, but now this guy writes a blog on it and suddenly all the outrage? I'm new to this game so I dont know the writer of this blog, but It seems like he has an axe to grind with erotica 1. It also seems that he is highly rated with the community, and using the ensuing **** storm to farther his witch hunt against erotica 1.
Please do note that I am looking at this from a completely neutral standing. I have no connections with the scam victim, erotica, or the blog writer. Unfortunately I sense that there is more to this story that erotica is hiding, and I sense that the blog writer is hiding something too...
Now onto the actual content of the recording itself...
In my opinion alot of this skirts right on the line and parts of it inches over the line. It was clear that through out the recording erotica was wording every ting he said carefully as to not cross the line. I do agree that a couple of his accomplices did cross the line and in a big way too, but you could tell that erotica himself was carefully wording what he was saying as to skirt the edge and not jump.
In the end while I do find this behavior very distasteful and potentially damaging to the game, I'm afraid there is not much that can be done. Since CCP knew about this particular case for about a month now and have done nothing I doubt they will now.
That being said I still semi-stand by my opening post in this thread. I believe that the scam victim does share a part of the responsibility here. There is no excuse for using racial slurrs.... EVER... for no reason. RL life threats? Bad idea on the internet, just saying... also I still stand by the fact that he could have left at any time, it wasn't like they were holding his family hostage here, we are just taling about Internet Pixels here.
TLDR summery:
65% erotica's fault for being a complete douche to this guy (prior to the outburst) 35% scam victims fault (Primarily for the racial slurs and RL death threat at end of recording) Blog writer has obvious vendetta against erotica |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
27
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 13:46:00 -
[9] - Quote
Delt0r Garsk wrote:LordOfDespair wrote:
If the majority of the players and nonplayers think this behavior is unacceptable, your argument is next to worthless.
The majority of eve players have hardly even heard of the forums let along this latest Erotica thing. They just don't care because its just not all that important.
^^ This
Also most people who do read the forums knew about this a month ago as I stated earlier... Which is why I'm wondering why the 9 million page thread now and not when this hit the forums last month. As stated before I think their is more to this story then what we are being led to believe.
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
27
|
Posted - 2014.03.26 14:01:00 -
[10] - Quote
LordOfDespair wrote:Everybody needs to stop assuming that the victims are perfectly healthy minded individuals.
"You deserve it if you fall for THAT scam."
"He could of left whenever he wanted!"
You have no idea who that person is, or what their life is right now.
He could be impaired someway mentally or not in the right state of mind. Does that make it right to abuse them for personal pleasure?
absolutely not
But lets be serious here. EVE isn't exactly WoW when it comes to the learning curve of the game. I really think that someone who was impaired enough to not have any idea what is going on around him would have an extremely hard time picking this game up, and would likely leave it out of frustration. Also he claims to be an air traffic controller... Not a job you get if your mentally deficient.
Lets face it, he got greedy, gambled and lost. That simple.
Does that make it right for erotica to treat a person in this matter regardless of circumstance? Absolutely not!!! Just dont expect anything to happen as this happened a while ago and was known to both CCP and the community long before this blog post or this thread.
|
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
31
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 07:49:00 -
[11] - Quote
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:sohkar wrote:i just got off the TS with erotica 1 and i did this to try to put a end to all this stuff people are putting out there and get how i felt about everything. I think all you people need to drop it. the "bonus room" happened over a month ago. Ask yourself why is it now just coming out now? if it wasnt for the article written about it no one would know or care. I did not know about your mis-adventure. But if I knew, I'd definitely care.
Sure... Do I really need to start linking the locked threads in C&P in regards to this particular 'bonus room' round? It was known the minute the recording was released. The only reason anyone cares now is a CSM representative is leading the mob and handing out the pitch forks. Prior to this moron posting this on his blog no one cared and it was known to the forum community long before this.
Its quite obvious that Mr. CSM has a deep hatred for ero, and in following through with this vendetta he drug sohkar, the whole eve community, and CCP down with ero.
Pretty sure the pitch forks are pointed in the wrong direction... Just saying |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
33
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 07:58:00 -
[12] - Quote
Coffee Rocks wrote:Kristalll wrote:Bloodmyst Ranwar wrote:Hmmm, so no official response from CCP yet.
Well it's good to know there are no boundaries when it comes to issues such as this. Harassment, bullying and humiliation is accepted in Eve Online.
Will be interesting to see how scams of this nature escalates, considering CCP hasn't given any official response yet. quit trying to relight the fire. Sohkar ended it himself. I know you really, really want it to be stamped out but it's just too late. You guys lit it and didn't realize EVERYONE would see. And ffs, Ripard is a good guy - why do you guys hate on him so much? <-- That's a serious Q, I really don't know what he did. Was it before my time? Or, was it just THIS? Because of him using Erotica's "Bonus Room" to highlight just how far into "horrible" we've let the community needle slide? I know you really, really want this to be the "end all", but sorry, it's not about the individual harmed. It's about the individuals that do the harming. Just for fun, I'm going to list a whole string of blogs people mailed to me that share our viewpoint (some call for bans, some don't, but are of the same theme). EVE Plex: Sociopath Callout: Erotica 1The Coffee Rocks: The AirlockJester's Trek: The Bonus RoundAlign to Ramble: Sociopaths In SpaceWarp To 0: Slippery SlopesMabrik's Mumblings: It's a Discussion the Gaming Community Needs to HaveEVE Inudstrialist: EVE (EVil Entities)Hardcore Casual: Too Much toleranceFoo's EVE Musings: The incident in a certain room
And whos fault is that? Here's a hint its not any one who was on the recording of this particular 'bonus room' round... |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
33
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 08:08:00 -
[13] - Quote
Morihei Akachi wrote:Asia Leigh wrote:Coffee Rocks wrote:Kristalll wrote:Bloodmyst Ranwar wrote:Hmmm, so no official response from CCP yet.
Well it's good to know there are no boundaries when it comes to issues such as this. Harassment, bullying and humiliation is accepted in Eve Online.
Will be interesting to see how scams of this nature escalates, considering CCP hasn't given any official response yet. quit trying to relight the fire. Sohkar ended it himself. I know you really, really want it to be stamped out but it's just too late. You guys lit it and didn't realize EVERYONE would see. And ffs, Ripard is a good guy - why do you guys hate on him so much? <-- That's a serious Q, I really don't know what he did. Was it before my time? Or, was it just THIS? Because of him using Erotica's "Bonus Room" to highlight just how far into "horrible" we've let the community needle slide? I know you really, really want this to be the "end all", but sorry, it's not about the individual harmed. It's about the individuals that do the harming. Just for fun, I'm going to list a whole string of blogs people mailed to me that share our viewpoint (some call for bans, some don't, but are of the same theme). EVE Plex: Sociopath Callout: Erotica 1The Coffee Rocks: The AirlockJester's Trek: The Bonus RoundAlign to Ramble: Sociopaths In SpaceWarp To 0: Slippery SlopesMabrik's Mumblings: It's a Discussion the Gaming Community Needs to HaveEVE Inudstrialist: EVE (EVil Entities)Hardcore Casual: Too Much toleranceFoo's EVE Musings: The incident in a certain room And whos fault is that? Here's a hint its not any one who was on the recording of this particular 'bonus room' round... So you assume that none of the authors of these pieces has actually listened to the recording themselves, that they've just uncritically copied what Ripard Teg says? You do them a disservice, I suspect.
Hmm... Did I actually say that in my post? Also have you even listened to the recording? The only thing remotely border line here was the 1 comment about his speech issues. It was one quick snide remark and never bought up again. I hear that ransoming someones ship or assets for singing on TS is a new and revaluating thing in eve. Amirite?
I ask again, Why is it that people care now when an idiot posts it on his blog and not when this hit the forums last month? |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
34
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 08:53:00 -
[14] - Quote
Coffee Rocks wrote:Asia Leigh wrote:
And whos fault is that? Here's a hint its not any one who was on the recording of this particular 'bonus room' round...
Gee. You are asking if Ripard should be to blame simply because he brought it up? For fun, let's play this game for just one more spin. A known arsonist lights a fire and burned down the city park. The fire burns itself out and the arsonist walks away, but not before posting a big sign in front of the park with pictures of himself lighting the fire, fanning the flames, and p**sing on the ashes. A few days go by and a local walks by and notices the ruined park. He tells the local journalist, who also happens to be a city councilman, and a story is run. The town's residents show up to the police station and demand the arsonist be made to leave town. Now, in your world, the police would instead arrest the councilman.
Surely you are trolling right? Last time I listened to this recording there were no rules or laws violated by ero... Maybe some borderline moral issues but nothing certainly against the rules. I'll listen to it again, but I'm sure it hasn't changed from when I heard it the first time last month when it first hit the forums. Or when I listened to it last night and surprised it was the same damn thing...
My question still stands, Why do people care about this when some idiot posts it on his blog and not when it hit the forums last month?
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
38
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 09:03:00 -
[15] - Quote
Ssieth wrote:Asia Leigh wrote:I ask again, Why is it that people care now when an idiot posts it on his blog and not when this hit the forums last month? Unlike most of the relevant questions here, that is an easy one to answer. Barely anyone read the original post on the forums.
That's funny, because the reason those threads were closed was because they got trolled off the forums and subsequently locked for trolling and personal attacks. Were was Mr. Blogger last month? I'm sorry I know this pisses people off, but if walks and quacks like a duck, its probably a duck.
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
40
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 09:06:00 -
[16] - Quote
Kaarous Aldurald wrote:So, I have to be going for a while now.
But so we can keep the hate train rolling, I feel that I should inform you all that while I am gone I will be spending at least 90 minutes sitting on a bench in WalMart, laughing at fat people.
Yours,
Kaarous.
Who knows, When you come back there will be 50 more pages of nonsense to read :D |

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
42
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 09:18:00 -
[17] - Quote
Infinity Ziona wrote:Once again, whether its now okay or not with the victim the line was crossed and cannot be uncrossed. If you're drink driving and don't kill anyone does that make it okay? No.
How much they paid him to be "okay with it" if they did, which is very highly likely given their questionable eithics is irrelevant.
This thread-naught, the multiple blogs, the posts on MMORPG, Massively and the rest slamming EVE, CCP, the player base is damage and the potential harm that it COULD HAVE CAUSED is the main issue.
As an aside I found it pretty amusing that someone... can't say who seems to have gone around and posted on sites that its suddenly okay, the victim is not upset, that the person who reported it is the evil one and oh yeah, could you please lock and delete these now... lol
*facepalm*
Have you listened to last nights stream?
And proof he was paid off to play nice? We wouldn't want to throw around baseless assumptions, now would we?
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
42
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 09:22:00 -
[18] - Quote
Kaius Fero wrote:Erotica 1 wrote:Alana Charen-Teng wrote:So I missed the twitch livestream today... what were the highlights? And how was the singing? I HAVE TO KNOW.
May this thread never die. Let's just say that after this is all over with I may be willing to sing songs and do silly things to win billions from total strangers. Will you also willing to use mayo to cover and massage your body? I'm not gay, but maybe other people would enjoy to see this...
Thanks, now I have an image in my head I'd rather not... CCP, ban him for giving me nightmares for 2 weeks straight... I feel bullied >.>
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
44
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 09:29:00 -
[19] - Quote
Infinity Ziona wrote:Asia Leigh wrote:Infinity Ziona wrote:Once again, whether its now okay or not with the victim the line was crossed and cannot be uncrossed. If you're drink driving and don't kill anyone does that make it okay? No.
How much they paid him to be "okay with it" if they did, which is very highly likely given their questionable eithics is irrelevant.
This thread-naught, the multiple blogs, the posts on MMORPG, Massively and the rest slamming EVE, CCP, the player base is damage and the potential harm that it COULD HAVE CAUSED is the main issue.
As an aside I found it pretty amusing that someone... can't say who seems to have gone around and posted on sites that its suddenly okay, the victim is not upset, that the person who reported it is the evil one and oh yeah, could you please lock and delete these now... lol *facepalm* Have you listened to last nights stream? And proof he was paid off to play nice? We wouldn't want to throw around baseless assumptions, now would we? I'm not interested in damage control and propaganda. I listened to the whole original recording. I don't have to provide proof since I wrote "if they did". Like I said its highly likely they would stoop to that level given their reputations for being scammers, liars and general asshats. Disclaimer: before you cry "personal attack" I said "given their reputations for being" which they cultivated themselves.
And so did I. In fact I listened to it twice. Once a month ago, and once yesterday. I bet you a third run through will still prove no rules or laws broken.
Obvious White Knight is Obvious
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
44
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 10:45:00 -
[20] - Quote
Prince Kobol wrote:Erotica 1 wrote:Your mistake was using the EVE client to blackmail me. You should have kept it all out of game. Like you do when you humiliate people for the purpose of your pleasure in order to try avoid any action by CCP?
As stated before, You know that holding peoples ship or assets ransom in exchange for public humiliation (ie, singing songs and making a general ass out of yourself) isnt anything exactly new to eve... |
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
47
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 10:46:00 -
[21] - Quote
KnowUsByTheDead wrote:Are we just trolling this thread now?
Yes
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
47
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 11:02:00 -
[22] - Quote
Prince Kobol wrote:Asia Leigh wrote:Prince Kobol wrote:Erotica 1 wrote:Your mistake was using the EVE client to blackmail me. You should have kept it all out of game. Like you do when you humiliate people for the purpose of your pleasure in order to try avoid any action by CCP? As stated before, You know that holding peoples ship or assets ransom in exchange for public humiliation (ie, singing songs and making a general ass out of yourself) isnt anything exactly new to eve... This is okay is it? So you admit that it is public humiliation and that is fine. Also just because something has been going on for a while it does not make it okay.
My point is why the out cry now when it has been known to have been going on since eve first launched. Hell someone posted earlier tonight a recording of a CCP Dev singing after getting caught and ransomed. Did that guy get banned? Doubt it... Was there this out cry for any of the other 'bonus room' recordings? How about all the other thousands upon thousands of people who are made to sing and get laughed at after being caught and ransomed? Did the pirates that caught those people get banned too? How about the out cry of support for them? Lets face it, its all the same crap...
You see where I'm going with this and why obvious witch hunt is obvious now?
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
47
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 11:11:00 -
[23] - Quote
Salvos Rhoska wrote:Remiel Pollard wrote:Please define 'most' and provide researched statistics to support up this assertion. Just about everyone who isn't directly profiting from the activities involved, either in the form of ISK or enjoying the recordings. You are the only ones defending this. Even those who are concerned about slippery slope consequences of intervention, don't actually approve of what is happening in the Bonus Room. The post history of this thread evidences that by means of the statistics of poster counts. The top posters are all associated with Erotica1 and profit from this activity. I am the only exception in that list. The rest is independant posters, most of who have expressed they find what happens in the Bonus Room goes too far. Thats why you and others profiting from the activity, constitute the top % of the posts, because you are forced to run daft amounts of damage control and interference against a dissenting majority. You know this, I know this, everyone knows this.
Hmm... Nowhere did I say I profit from the 'bonus round' isk wise... Nor did I say I enjoy listening to the recordings. In fact I never actually said that I support ero's activities at all? All I said that based on what I have heard and read this looks like a witch hunt against ero... But if you actually took the time to actually read the posts you would know that now, Would you?
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
47
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 11:14:00 -
[24] - Quote
Alp Khan wrote:
Do you know any CCP developer that felt compelled to send Erotica 1 pictures of a boyfriend/girlfriend? Or any CCP developer that felt compelled to write Erotica 1 on his/her body with mayonnaise? Perhaps some CCP developer which had their disabled partner go into a screaming panic attack as a result of interaction with Erotica 1?
Go ahead, I'm listening.
Recorded proof?
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
48
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 11:27:00 -
[25] - Quote
KnowUsByTheDead wrote:Asia Leigh wrote:KnowUsByTheDead wrote:Are we just trolling this thread now?
Yes Meh, as much as I would like to stay and fight over whether or not people can disconnect from their "video game" avatar... Get over themselves... And just HTFU... I gotta go to bed. But I will say this. Talking to sohkar in Escrow chat after all of the festivities ended, he was still innocent enough, and "new" enough, despite his old aged character, to not realize how deep the politics of this game run. Kinda sad really, that he was thrust into the spotlight, little more than a newbie, to serve as a tool for a CSM member's grudge against one player. As for the remaining Ero hate, he has already given you what you want. The characters are being gutted. Because quite frankly, internet spaceships is not serious business. It is a game, made for people to play the villain. Key word being "play." And while sohkar understands he acted out of bounds with his anger, and while he doesn't agree with Erotica's playstyle, he still respects that it was a game. He even got back on his feet in just a day or two, lol. That is a player I can respect, no matter his profession. Holding his head high. Took a lot of courage for him to announce his distaste in Ripard's maneuvering, and lack of consent. Especially amongst the scammers who scammed him. But yet, in an environment that is completely friendly and amicable. Good for him. Good night all, and thanks for the wonderful forum PvP. 
^^ What he just said ^^
although I still hold my ground that ero playong contestant in his 'bonus room' is just an attention ***** thing, everything he basically said is true and to the point and can be backed with solid evidence...
Once again, this does not mean I condone the behavior, but it does fall with in the rules
|

Asia Leigh
Beyond New Frontier
48
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 11:29:00 -
[26] - Quote
Alp Khan wrote:Danalee wrote:Is the TEAMSPEAK BONUS ROOM of Erotica 1 any official EVE online channel? Do you really think you are deceiving anybody here? D.  Oh wow, surely the victims who got into that TEAMSPEAK BONUS ROOM happened to waltz in there through sheer coincidence and not because they were told to do so through EVE Online.
irrelevant
|
|
|
|